Hi Scott,
Since it worked on a fresh install but not on the two upgraded hosts, this could be related to leftover config settings from ESXi 7. A few things to check:
Try setting it manually in the host configuration file
Instead of using ESXCLI or PowerCLI, try adding the setting manually in:
Look for /system/advanced/Syslog.global.auditRecord.storageCapacity and try modifying it there, then reboot the host.
Check VMSA restrictions
Run:
If the setting is locked (Locked: true
), ESXi might be enforcing restrictions due to STIG compliance mode or a policy applied to upgraded hosts.
Compare policies between hosts
Since the fresh install worked, check for policy differences:
Compare the output from a working host and a failing one to see if something is blocking the change.