Storage

 View Only

Using vscsiStats for Storage Performance Analysis 

May 29, 2009 10:28 PM

Introduction

esxtop is a great tool for performance analysis of all types.  However,  with only latency and throughput statistics, esxtop will not provide the  full picture of the storage profile.  Furthermore, esxtop only provides  latency numbers for Fibre Channel and iSCSI storage.  Latency analysis  of NFS traffic is not possible with esxtop.

Since ESX 3.5, VMware has provided a tool specifically for profiling  storage: vscsiStats.  vscsiStats collects and reports counters on  storage activity.  Its data is collected at the virtual SCSI device  level in the kernel.  This means that results are reported per VMDK (or  RDM) irrespective of the underlying storage protocol.  The following  data are reported in histogram form:

  • IO size
  • Seek distance
  • Outstanding IOs
  • Latency (in microseconds)
  • More!

Running vscsiStats

vscsiStats collection and analysis requires two steps:

  1. Start statistics collection.
  2. View accrued statistics.

Documentation on command-line parameters are available when running '/usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -h'.

Starting and Stopping vscsiStats Collection

The tool is started with the following command:

/usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -s -w <world_group_id>

This command starts the process that will accrue statistics.  The world  group ID must be set to a running virtual machine.  The running VMs' IDs  can be obtained by running '/usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -l'.

After about 30 minutes vscsiStats will stop running.  If the analysis is  needed for a longer period, the start command should be repeated above  in this window.  That will defer the timeout and termination by another  30 minutes.

Since results are accrued and reported out in summary, the histograms  will include data since collection was started.  To reset all counters  to zero, run '/usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -r'.

Viewing Statistics

Counters are displayed by using the following command:

/usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -p <histo_type> [-c]

The histogram type is used to specify either all of the statistics or  one group of them.  Options include all, ioLength, seekDistance,  outstandingIOs, latency, interarrival.

Results can be produced in a more compact comma-delimited list by adding the optional "-c" above.

Using vscsiStats Results

Use Case 1: Identifying Sequential IO

Storage arrays can process sequential IO much faster than random IO.   You can therefore improve the performance of a sequential workload by  placing it on a dedicated LUN to allow the array to optimize access.   vscsiStats can help you identify your sequential workloads even if you  don't understand anything about the application in the VM.

Take the following graph as example, which I generated by running '/usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -p seekDistance':



This graph shows that most of the commands are being issued a great  distance from the previous command.  It looks like all of the commands  were 50,000 or more logical blocks away from the previous command.  When  I looked at the raw data, I saw that over 99% of the commands were more  than 128 blocks away from the previous command.  That's random access  if I've ever seen it.  Here's the opposite example:



In this case the logical block number (LBN) of each command is most  frequently exactly one larger than the previous command.  That's the  signature of a heavily sequential workload.  It shouldn't surprise you  to learn that both of these profiles were generated by Iometer using  random and sequential writes, respectively.

Use Case 2: Optimizing for IO Sizes

The IO size is an important characteristic of storage profiles.  A  variety of best practices have been provided by storage vendors to  enable customers to tune their storage to a particular IO size.  As an  example, it may make sense to optimize an array's stripe size to its  average IO size.  vscsiStats can provide a histogram of IO sizes to help  this process.  The following graph was generated by  '/usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -p ioLength':



From these results I can see that about a quarter of the commands came  in IOs smaller than 4k.  About half of the commands were sized to 4k  commands.  The minute number of remaining IOs were larger than 4k.  This  signature is common of a VMDK formatted to 4k blocks and supporting OS  and application execution.  The storage array should be optimized for 4k  blocks if this disk's performance is a priority.

Use Case 3: Storage Latency Analysis (Including NFS!)

esxtop is a terrific tool for latency-based storage analysis.  Fibre  Channel and iSCSI HBAs have device and kernel latencies in esxtop's  storage panel.  Software iSCSI initiators will show up as vmhba32 (ESX  3.5 and earlier) and vmhba33 (ESX 4.0 and later.)  But esxtop does not  provide latency statistics for NFS stores.

Because vscsiStats collects its results where the guest interacts with  the hypervisor, it is unaware of the storage implementation.  Latency  statistics can be collected for all storage configurations with this  tool.



The above graph shows that the server in my office with a single  direct-attached SCSI disk is performing as I would expect.  About half  of all the operations are completing in under 5 ms.  The other half take  5-15 ms to complete.  A few commands took longer than 15 ms, but the  number is so small that it doesn't concern me.  Similar results can be  seen with NFS arrays.

vscsiStats on ESXi

vscsiStats can be installed on ESXi hosts after putting the host into  tech support mode.  More information on this process is availalble on Scott's blog on the subject on vPivot.

Additional Resources

My colleagues Ajay Gulati, Chethan Kumar, and Irfan Ahmad presented at VPACT 09 Storage Workload Characterization and Consolidation in Virtualized Enviornments.  This paper serves as an excellent example of vscsiStats in action.

I learned vscsiStats by reviewing Irfan's VMworld 2007 presentation (vscsiStats: Fast and Easy Disk Workload Characterization on VMware ESX Server) and playing with the tool.  Check out his presentation if you'd like more detail.

Statistics
0 Favorited
0 Views
0 Files
0 Shares
0 Downloads

Tags and Keywords

Comments

Mar 11, 2019 07:36 AM

Did anyone used from this for define parameters for VFLASH ?

Jul 11, 2011 06:27 PM

Also, for what it's worth, CopperEgg has a tool that shows latency and usage metrics in real-time, but it's not vmware specific - it can work on any vendor or storage subsystem.  http://copperegg.com

Eric

Jan 28, 2011 05:39 AM

It looks like the sample data pictures are no longer working in the use Case example section of this document.  Instead, there are just broken link images where the graphics should be.  Any chance that somebody at VMware can check into that when they get a moment?

EDIT:  Never mind.  I just noticed there's an archive kept of previous revisions.  I was able to go back to previous version of the DOC and grab the images from there to update the current one.  Took me a couple tries to get them all to appear properly, but I got them there in the end :smileyhappy:

Aug 15, 2010 03:20 PM

Yes, both ESX(i) 4.1 contain the vscsiStats utility, in previous ESXi versions you had to download it from VMware and in 4.1 I can confirm it's included in the usual path /usr/lib/vmware/bin

=========================================================================

William Lam

VMware vExpert 2009,2010

VMware scripts and resources at:

Twitter: @lamw

vGhetto Script Repository

Getting Started with the vMA (tips/tricks)

Getting Started with the vSphere SDK for Perl

VMware Code Central - Scripts/Sample code for Developers and Administrators

VMware Developer Community

If you find this information useful, please award points for "correct" or "helpful".

Aug 15, 2010 03:04 PM

Now that vSphere 4.1 is GA can someone confirm that vscsiStats is included in ESXi 4.1? I ask because our VMware reps were onsite (after the GA date) for the "what's new in vSphere 4.1" slide show and one of the slides indicated that vSphere 4.1 includes vscsiStats, but I have not seen or heard this anywhere else.

Aug 04, 2010 08:19 AM

Anybody allready figured out the relation between a handleid from vscsistats to a vmdk?

I tried the run patsie-842974, but I don't get any information. Maybe someone can help me with this.

Thnx

Feb 25, 2010 08:36 PM

I figured out the pattern for the handle IDs.

The virtual SCSI handle Id is determined by looking first at IDE HDs and then SCSI HDs. The handle Ids are contiguous with regards to the x:y adapter:target numbering scheme with IDE taking precedence.

Here is the Python library I wrote to create a map between handle Ids and the VMDK files.

http://pastie.org/842974

Feb 18, 2010 11:55 PM

Hi,

still working with vscsiStats, very nice tool!

I'm currently trying to get some fine-grained statistics, so I (in a loop) reset the stats, sleep for some seconds and then print the histograms. This works fine overall, however I sometimes see vscsiStats errors (error code 0xbad0094, Failed fetch VSI node (hasVmm)) and/or absurdly high numbers (e.g. 1193970 seconds for max IO write latency). Seems that happens more often (or only?) on ESX4i.

Any idea what I'm doing wrong?

Jan 20, 2010 10:39 PM

I've come up with a way to map the VMDKs to HandleIDs in a conclusive manner (takes time into account): http://communities.vmware.com/message/1460390#1460390

Jan 13, 2010 06:29 PM

Also answered on vPivot:

http://vpivot.com/2009/10/21/vscsistats-for-esxi/#comments

The beta program is invite only. Please contact your account team for an invitation.

Scott

More information on my blog and on Twitter:

http://vpivot.com

http://twitter.com/drummonds

Jan 13, 2010 03:26 AM

Hey, don't blame me for trying :smileyhappy:

Fair enough. Of course the next logical question is: what does it take to get a hand on a development (or beta) version?

Best,

Norbert

Jan 13, 2010 01:42 AM

Is it just coincidence that I had to dodge this question on my blog just an hour ago? :smileyhappy:

I provided the best answer VMware can give in the comments section to the blog on vscsiStats for ESXi:

http://vpivot.com/2009/10/21/vscsistats-for-esxi/#comments

Scott

More information on my blog and on Twitter:

http://vpivot.com

http://twitter.com/drummonds

Jan 13, 2010 01:19 AM

Hi,

I heard rumors that the next version of ESX (ESX 4.1 ?) will have NFS stats available via SOAP. Any idea if is that correct?

Best,

Norbert

Dec 22, 2009 08:01 PM

Basically that. But of course the online version of that formula.

Irfan

Dec 22, 2009 08:00 PM

Just one last question- hopefully before you go in your (I'm sure well-deserved) vacation: how is the mean calculated? Is that the same as the average (i.e. sum of all packet sizes divided by number of packets?)

</nk>

Dec 22, 2009 07:36 PM

The two things you want connected don't exist in the same universe :smileyhappy: Still, the larger point is that this analysis should be easier to do. Ideally this data should be available even through the vCenter API.

If you find this data useful (especially take a look at http://communities.vmware.com/docs/DOC-10104 for ideas on how far you can stretch this analysis), please consider filing a feature request for the plumbing of the stats.

Yes to bytes. Means are calculated online before data is inserted into the histogram. Off to vacation now. Look forward to your comments on the storage workload characterization paper referred to above.

Irfan

Dec 22, 2009 07:22 PM

Yeah, thanks for the clarification. Would still be helpful if there were somewhere an explicit mapping between the vSCSI handleIDs and the VirtualDisk object accessible via mob/SOAP (I mean other then the ordering of the Ids which I'm using right now).

Anyway, thanks a lot for all the comments. Oh, and am I correct to assume that the unit for the ioLength histograms is bytes, and that the "mean" is calculated over the real length of the packets and not from the histogram?

</nk>

Dec 22, 2009 07:17 PM

FWIW: I really think that the folks active on this thread should take a good look at http://communities.vmware.com/docs/DOC-10104. The paper referenced there and published at VPACT is a great resource for comparing your workloads' vscsi stats with those of 5 major benchmarks and also understanding the performance costs and benefits of consolidation.

Internally, we refer to that paper a lot when trying to understand new workloads we observe.

IMHO, that should really be required reading for vSphere storage admins.

Irfan

Dec 22, 2009 06:57 PM

All virtual disks have vscsi handles (and therefore handle IDs).

If you suspend/resume, vmotion/svmotion or initiate any other such operations that require registration of virtual disks, of course, the IDs will change.

These IDs are really just opaque identifiers to uniquely identify virtual disks and you should not infer any semantics from them since the semantics are likely to change in the future.

Irfan

Dec 21, 2009 07:16 PM

Can I rely on the fact the the vSCSI handleIDs only change at VM boot time. What about hot-swapping (e.g. are disks added to a VM while it's running visible/accessible to the VM before the next reboot)?

Just curious: is there any other place these vSCSI handleIDs (or the worldGroupIDs) are used?\

I will of course test all this in my lab...

</nk>

Dec 20, 2009 05:05 AM

If what @irfan.ahmad says is true about the the mapping of vscsiStats output to VMDK order in the VM configuration, then as @nkiesel pointed out this can easily be retrieved usign the VI/vSphere API.

@nkiesel, There is a unique key for each Device that is kept track on a per VM basis, hence you may see repetitive values such as 2000,2001,etc. as VMDK(s) afaik starts at 2000 and increments by 1 and actuallyt he users can change the labels to whatever their heart desires, if the order is kept upon the creation of the devices then it should be trivial to map.

Here is a script I wrote awhile back that retrieves some info about VM's disk, I've added an additional attribute to capture the VMDK SCSI adapter and target value (SCSI X:Y).

Take a look here for more details:

Here's an example:

script output:

[vi-admin@scofield ~] $ ./getVMDiskInfo.pl --server reflex.primp-industries.com --username primp

esxi4-1
        Hard disk 1 = [himalaya-local-SATA.RE4-GP:Storage] esxi4-1/esxi4-1.vmdk
        Hard disk 1 = isThinProvsioned
        Hard disk 1 = persistent
        Hard disk 1 = VirtualDiskFlatVer2BackingInfo
        Hard disk 1 = SCSI(0:0)

        Hard disk 2 = [himalaya-local-SATA.RE4-GP:Storage] esxi4-1/esxi4-1_1.vmdk
        Hard disk 2 = isThinProvsioned
        Hard disk 2 = persistent
        Hard disk 2 = VirtualDiskFlatVer2BackingInfo
        Hard disk 2 = SCSI(3:13)

        Hard disk 3 = [himalaya-local-SATA.RE4-GP:Storage] esxi4-1/esxi4-1_2.vmdk
        Hard disk 3 = isThinProvsioned
        Hard disk 3 = persistent
        Hard disk 3 = VirtualDiskFlatVer2BackingInfo
        Hard disk 3 = SCSI(3:2)

        Hard disk 4 = [himalaya-local-SATA.RE4-GP:Storage] esxi4-1/esxi4-1_3.vmdk
        Hard disk 4 = isThinProvsioned
        Hard disk 4 = persistent
        Hard disk 4 = VirtualDiskFlatVer2BackingInfo
        Hard disk 4 = SCSI(0:4)

        Hard disk 5 = [himalaya-local-SATA.RE4-GP:Storage] esxi4-1/esxi4-1_4.vmdk
        Hard disk 5 = isThinProvsioned
        Hard disk 5 = persistent
        Hard disk 5 = VirtualDiskFlatVer2BackingInfo
        Hard disk 5 = SCSI(2:5)

vscsiStats output:

[root@himalaya ~]# /usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -l

.....

Virtual Machine worldGroupID: 40133, Virtual Machine Display Name: esxi4-1 {
   Virtual SCSI Disk handleID: 8578
   Virtual SCSI Disk handleID: 8579
   Virtual SCSI Disk handleID: 8580
   Virtual SCSI Disk handleID: 8581
   Virtual SCSI Disk handleID: 8582
}

From this output, you should be able to map the vSCSI handleID which are just counters that are initiate for each disk and will change as a VM is powered on/off, similar to worldGroupID.

I haven't done extensively testing, but you should be able to validate this by adding load on certain disks and see if it maps back as @irfan.ahmad said

=========================================================================

William Lam

VMware vExpert 2009

VMware ESX/ESXi scripts and resources at: http://engineering.ucsb.edu/~duonglt/vmware/

Twitter: @lamw

vGhetto Script Repository

VMware Code Central - Scripts/Sample code for Developers and Administrators

VMware Developer Comuunity

If you find this information useful, please award points for "correct" or "helpful".

Dec 19, 2009 11:20 PM

Sorry, I'm not a scripting expert. Maybe someone else can chip in to help. If possible, I'd like to get a hold of the final script you write though for future reference.

Irfan

Dec 19, 2009 04:02 AM

Great! So I could do the following to find this:

1) find the hardware for the VM (e.g. via /mob/?moid=3904&doPath=config.hardware)

2) iterate over the virtual devices and find those of type VirtualDisk and look at their deviceInfo.label (e.g. "Hard Disk 1")

3) for these devices look at the backing.datastore to find out on which datastore they are located

and then map the datastores to the handleIDs in the same order.

Works for me as long as users can't change the labels of the devices (can they)? Or should I rely on the key attribute instead (first disk aways seems to have 2000, next one 2001 etc).

Thanks for the help and have a great weekend!

Dec 19, 2009 03:20 AM

The virtual disks should be presented to the VM in list order of that output. So, Hard Disk 1 should be the first one presented and so forth.

Irfan

Dec 19, 2009 02:28 AM

Not really. What I see for e.g. a virtual machine that uses 2 hard disks (one on iSCSI and one on NFS) is:# /usr/lib/vmware/bin/vscsiStats -l

Virtual Machine worldGroupID: 1144, Virtual Machine Display Name: Probe {

Virtual SCSI Disk handleID: 8200

Virtual SCSI Disk handleID: 8210

}

The histograms refer to the worldGroupID and handleID, but how do I know if 8200 is the iSCSI or the NFS disk?

Dec 19, 2009 01:44 AM

try vscsiStats -l and let me know if that helped at all. That's -l as in 'dash' 'el'.

Irfan

Dec 19, 2009 01:41 AM

How can I link the worldgroupIds and virtual disk handleIDs to objects in the rest of the world? I could of course find e.g. the VM uuid by doing a lookup using SOAP for that machine, but what about the disks if e.g. a VM uses more than one disk?

Oct 27, 2009 05:56 AM

I think you have seen my blog about this already, but I have updated this document to answer your question.

Scott

More information on my blog and on Twitter:

http://vpivot.com

http://twitter.com/drummonds

Oct 07, 2009 04:37 PM

lamw: see my response to aenagy of Sep 17.

Oct 07, 2009 05:48 AM

Is vscsiStats actually available for ESXi? I was under the impression it was only available on Service Console with the classic ESX

=========================================================================

William Lam

VMware vExpert 2009

VMware ESX/ESXi scripts and resources at: http://engineering.ucsb.edu/~duonglt/vmware/

vGhetto Script Repository

VMware Code Central - Scripts/Sample code for Developers and Administrators

VMware Developer Comuunity

Twitter: @lamw

If you find this information useful, please award points for "correct" or "helpful".

Sep 28, 2009 02:06 PM

Will do.

Thanks.

Sep 17, 2009 08:58 PM

aenagy: please get in touch with drummonds (author of this communities doc) if you need access to vscsiStats on ESXi. Stopping deployment of ESXi should not be gated on this issue.

Sep 14, 2009 12:13 AM

Irfan:

I am getting ready to roll out vSphere and still debating ESX vs. ESXi. There is no problem at this time, I just want to be prepared if we encounter performance problems.

Sep 13, 2009 11:21 PM

aenagy: Can you describe your use case a little bit please?

Irfan

Sep 13, 2009 02:32 PM

Irfan:

You mentioned at VMworld 2009 that you would like to see vscsiStats included in vCenter. Do you know if this is going to happen? Soon? If not soon, then will there be an ESXi version? My recommendation to roll-out ESX 4.0 vs. ESXi 4.0 would be influenced by the availability of vscsiStats-like data gathering.

Thanks.

Aug 24, 2009 05:35 PM

In case folks are interested in learning more about how this stuff works under the hood, take a look at my related blog posts and read the IISWC academic paper on the topic as well.

Finally, Scott is planning on covering vscsiStats usage in detail during his performance labs at VMworld 2009.

Irfan

Related Entries and Links

No Related Resource entered.