Idea Details

Comments within EventDisp-Files disappear after modifications with the Event Configurator

Last activity 05-31-2019 01:55 AM
Rene Wiesmueller's profile image
08-21-2013 06:01 AM

Hi,

 

one of our customers added some comments within EventDisp files.
If he then modifies the configuration with the Event Configurator, the comments are no longer available.
It seems that the corresponding EventDisp file is compiled again, after the changes were saved and therefore the comments disappear.

 

So it would be nice, if it is possible to keep the comments within the EventDisp files.
Otherwise, the customer has to add them every time, after he made some modifications with the EC.


Comments

11-30-2015 03:19 AM

Thank you, Nagesh.

I understand, that you can't say more, but please, wait not to long.

And ...

here is the link for the new idea:

Don't destroy formattings of the Spectrum EventDisp and CsEvFormat files after modifications with the Event Configurator

11-30-2015 12:49 AM

Hello Frank_Elliger,

 

Sorry for late reply on this. As per legal guidelines I cannot refer or comment on specific release . But this is in our radar and we want to pursue this.

 

Yes. We will need a separate idea for formatting. We are considering this idea to take care the comments part.

 

Thanks,

Nagesh

11-24-2015 07:37 AM

Yes, please, i hate when the update delete all comments =)

11-23-2015 10:34 AM

Hi, Nagesh_Jaiswal,

could  you  explain "for next release of Spectrum" a lit bit more.

At the DACHSUG Meeting in October Kathy Hickey spoke about Spectrum 10.1.1.

Do you mean this?

And when will something happen with formatting?

Do you need a separate idea for  this?

Regards, Frank

11-23-2015 10:22 AM

Hi christian_h,

 

Not yet. But we will prioritized this for next release of Spectrum.

 

Thanks,

Nagesh

11-23-2015 09:16 AM

Hi Nagesh,

 

do you have any information within which relase this will be fixed/implemented ?


Regards,

Christian

07-22-2015 12:32 PM

Hi Andre_H,

 

We are right now only focusing to retain the comments in EventDisp file. Formatting part is under review.

 

Thanks,

Nagesh

07-22-2015 08:16 AM

Hi Nagesh,

 

thanks for the feedback. One question, is it planned to set the feature for the EventDisp file only or for the CsEvFormat, too?

 

Thanks,

Andre

07-22-2015 05:42 AM

Folks,

 

This idea is lined up and planned for future releases of CA Spectrum.

 

Thanks,

Nagesh

07-02-2015 06:30 AM

Hi Nagesh,

 

I do see the same behavior for the CsEvFormat files. As soon as I save an event in the GUI, the content of CsEvFormat file will be set in a single line, too. The single lined content does not provide a good overview about the contents.

 

So all in all a save at the GUI site

- formatting of EventDisp and CsEvFormat files will be lost

- all comments in EventDisp will be lost

Both effects have a negative impact for a well-structured event customization.


Do you have any first results of your investigation?

 

Thanks,
Andre

05-14-2015 09:46 AM

Thanks for the update Frank_Elliger

 

We will review this as well.

 

Thanks,

Nagesh

05-05-2015 03:29 AM

Hi Nagesh,

not only the comments  will be lost, , but also any formatting.

Here an example:

My version:

0x210c0e R CA.EventCondition, "(regexp({v 3}, {S \"Syslog\"}) && regexp({v 4}, {S \"ASA\"}))" , "0xfff11001 -:-", /

               "(regexp({v 3}, {S \"OVERTEMP\"}))" , "0xfff14001 -:-", /

               "({v 2} == {I 1}) || ({v 2} == {I 2})" , "0x21001c -:-", /

               "({v 2} == {I 3}) || ({v 2} == {I 4})" , "0x21001b -:-", /

               "({v 2} == {I 5})" , "0x21001a -:-", /

               "default" , "0x210017 -:-"

 

"Spectrums version":

0x210c0e R CA.EventCondition, "(regexp({v 3}, {S \"Syslog\"}) && regexp({v 4}, {S \"ASA\"}))" , "0xfff11001 -:-","(regexp({v 3}, {S \"OVERTEMP\"}))" , "0xfff14001 -:-","({v 2} == {I 1}) || ({v 2} == {I 2})" , "0x21001c -:-","({v 2} == {I 3}) || ({v 2} == {I 4})" , "0x21001b -:-","({v 2} == {I 5})" , "0x21001a -:-","default" , "0x210017 -:-"

 

If you use both methods (editing the event disp files and sometimes the EventConfiguration), you will get this effect.

Regards, Frank

05-05-2015 01:53 AM

Thanks al.sorrell. We will further review this and get back with an update.

05-04-2015 01:35 PM

This has been a long-standing issue with Spectrum. If you create your EventDisp file by hand, and include comments, e.g.

# CDP DUPLEX_MISMATCH - Minor

0xfff00109 E 50 A 1, 0xfff00109

 

If you then go into Tools > Utilities > Event Configuration and make any change, all of the comments embedded in the EventDisp file will be lost when you exit and save the file,

04-16-2015 04:14 AM

Thanks for posting this idea for CA Spectrum.

 

We need more clarification on this idea. Exact steps to reproduce would help.

 

Thanks,

Nagesh