Thanks John for your input and sorry another open source project spoiled it for your management. Why they cant judge things on a case by case basis..like life...is puzzling..things are not black and white
For others who are have not considered Klement's open source my rational is:
1. If IBM Champion Jon Paris sayshttp://www.ibmsystemsmag.com/ibmi/developer/rpg/web_service_rest/Scott Klement’s HTTPAPI is an excellent tool to let RPG programs consume both REST and SOAP Web services. Then who am I to argue.
2. You have all the source no black boxes, could be argued CA Plex with its runtimes and no source poses a greater risk
3. Klement's user base may well be bigger than CA Plex user base
4. Klement's HTTPAPI project has active forum
5 .IBM uses open source IBM Systems Magazine - XMLSERVICE Offers New Life for RPG Programs.
6. Klements is the highest quality code I personally have ever seen, multiple times better than what I have worked with over the years.
7. A way to introduce new techniques and best practice to IBMi shop and to learn yourself
8. Mature (2003) and stable but uses more up to date techniques than CA Plex generated source
9. Constantly being improved and functionality added to as opposed to CA Plex patterns
10. Free
Predictably a by product of using and getting to know the source (always advisable with open source) was I learnt further how CA Plex generated source with its goto tags is light years behind modern free format RPG. And the limitations of CA Plex were highlighted for example by not supporting subprocedures in the action diagram.